SEA-PHAGES Logo

The official website of the HHMI Science Education Alliance-Phage Hunters Advancing Genomics and Evolutionary Science program.

Welcome to the forums at seaphages.org. Please feel free to ask any questions related to the SEA-PHAGES program. Any logged-in user may post new topics and reply to existing topics. If you'd like to see a new forum created, please contact us using our form or email us at info@seaphages.org.

Membrane protein

| posted 18 Jan, 2019 16:47
Does a gene that BLASTs to Membrane protein, Band-7-like need to have multiple transmembrane domains to call it Membrane protein, Band-7-like?
Edited 18 Jan, 2019 19:35
| posted 19 Jan, 2019 13:55
No. Band-7 proteins are their own class.

Thanks for asking!
| posted 30 Jan, 2019 21:13
Would it be possible to get greater clarification for the function assignment 'membrane protein?'

The online bioinformatics guide states the following "a protein can be assigned the function "membrane protein" based on the results of the programs TMHMM and/or SOSUI. We use this assignment if we find two or more potential membrane domains predicted by one of the programs, or, a single membrane domain predicted with confidence by both programs."

The official function list seems to require 2 confirmed transmembrane domains for the function 'membrane protein' to be called.

Is it acceptable to assign the function membrane protein with only 1 TM confirmed by TMHMM and SOSUI?
Thank you for any guidance!

| posted 01 Feb, 2019 03:50
Hi Denise,
If you find one transmembrane domain with TMHMM, you can only call it a membrane protein if you can validate it with a different transmembrane finder (such as SOSUI). (If two different algorithms detect a trans membrane domain, you can hopefully rule out false positives.)
Does that clarify it?
debbie
| posted 01 Feb, 2019 19:23
Yes - I just hesitated when I saw the new note associated with the function 'membrane protein' in the Official Function List at seaphages.org. It reads "at least two (2) transmembrane domains found using TMHMM." My group was assigning the function 'membrane protein' using the 'rules' outlined in the Bioinformatics Guide and which you re-iterated above. The clarification is helpful. Thank you!
| posted 11 Mar, 2019 18:36
Hi,

SOSUI is down. We contacted the host, and we do not know when it will be back up. We see that TMHMM predicts one transmembrane domain. The Official Function list says we need two domains called by TMHMM. This means we cannot call it a membrane protein, correct? Why does it have to have two domains?
| posted 15 Mar, 2019 02:54
Erin,
I don't think it has to have 2 domains, it just has to have 1 convincing one. The problem is that one program doesn't have adequate sensitivity. So if there is only one, we want it verified by 2 sources. Without the option to 'verify' a transmembrane domain with a second program, let's not add it as a function.
 
Login to post a reply.